The Reds' best years are behind them unless they finally build a
Yeah nah, our backs could be the second coming of the Bedroom Boys and it'd mean nothing if the scrum keeps folding like a deck chair at Suncorp. Petaia and Daugunu running off clean ball is lovely in theory, where's that ball coming from when we're shoved off our own ball? Honest question: does the academy actually recruit props, or just more outside backs because they look flash on highlights? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Yeah nah, our backs could be the second coming of the Bedroom Boys and it'd mean nothing if the scrum keeps folding like a deck chair at Suncorp. Petaia and Daugunu running off clean ball is lovely in theory, where's tha…
Funny how "folding like a deck chair" survived 2021-22 when our scrum was genuinely solid. Not convinced the pack's gone backwards since. Receipts please.
Numbers are honest, takes aren't.
Scrum10 mate, 2021 was great yeah but one decent season doesn't fix the last few years 🔥 Watched us get pumped backwards at Suncorp too many times to count tbh. All that Petaia brilliance means nothing off lost ball. We back them all day, just want some props to run behind 💪 Ah well, nowt to do but keep turning up eh
Fair challenge from Scrum10, and I'd give him partial credit. 2021-22 was genuinely solid up front, I tracked our scrum penalty differential that season and it held up in most matches. Small sample though - one good stretch doesn't tell you much about whether the development pipeline works, and that's where I reckon the real question sits.
LockLegend's point lands for me because the pattern since has been uneven: some nights the pack holds, others we get marched at Suncorp and Petaia's touches dry up completely. If our academy were consistently producing front-rowers, we wouldn't see that swing. I could be wrong, but I'd want to compare props developed locally against those recruited before calling the academy a write-off 📊
Context beats a bare stat.
Remember watching Horan and Flatley run off a pack that shoved everyone around. Makes me wonder if we can ever get back there 😢 Do we even know where the prop pipeline went?
Scrum10 wants receipts, fair, but watch a Reds academy session sometime and tell me how many tight-five prospects you count. Pipeline dried up years back, no mystery there.
Supporter88 is spot on about the tight-five, honestly. I still remember going to Ballymore as a kid and the props were everywhere, what happened? 😅
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Wellington_15 hits the nail on the head. Everyone wanted to be a flashy centre, nobody wanted the tight-five hard yakka 🤡 Remind me of the Reds' scrum record last season, exactly? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Hard yakka doesn't sell jerseys though, does it 😅 Kids at Ballymore all wanna be the next Petaia, no one's dreaming about propping a scrum in 34-degree heat. And Napier_Legend, you know fine well that scrum record last season was ugly - no need to dig it up again, we all sat through it 🤬
ChrisQueenstown nailed it, kids dream about the flash stuff, always have. But word from a source close to Ballymore is the coaching set-up there changed a while back and prop development quietly slipped down the list 😏 They'll fix it, or they won't. Those who know, know.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
ChrisQueenstown nailed it, kids dream about the flash stuff, always have. But word from a source close to Ballymore is the coaching set-up there changed a while back and prop development quietly slipped down the list 😏 T…
@Wing_Fan sounds like typical "my mate's cousin said" gossip tbh 🙄 but every club that lets scrum coaching drift ends up munted up front — I coached juniors and even there we drill body position every session
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Source on that, Wing_Fan? "Word from a source" is exactly the vague stuff I keep seeing here. If coaching priorities actually shifted, name when and who. Otherwise it's just gossip dressed as insight.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping's got a point, Wing_Fan - "those who know, know" means nothing without a name and a date. But I'd say the gossip smells right even if the detail's thin. Watch the TAB markets around our scrum games: the line against us at Suncorp keeps getting uglier and no one's steaming in to back our pack. Punters vote with real money, that tells you more than any unnamed source.
So where does that leave us? I've had my multi salted on the Reds plenty of times and it's usually the backs legs that land, the pack leg is the one that torches the ticket 🔥. Can't call it either way yet: coaching could genuinely have slipped, or the talent pool for tight-five just dried up like everywhere else. Until I see a Wallabies-capped prop come out of Ballymore again, I'm keeping the forward-pack leg off my ticket 😭
Don't laugh, but what does "prop development slipped down the list" actually mean in practice? Fewer scrum sessions? Thanks guys 🙏
Bloody hell, you keep seeing these kinds of reports and you start to think the whole system is just built on smoke. When the foundational stuff like the scrum work starts slipping, that is a huge red flag for any punter …
@JoshBeliever nah no laughs mate, fair question. It's usually not just scrum sessions dropping off, it's who's running them and whether the young props get real minutes against grown men. I coach the juniors up here and even at that level if you skip two weeks of body height drills you see it straight away 😅 Clubs chase flashy backs stuff and the front row quietly gets neglected 🔥
You don't abandon your own.
Bloody hell, you keep seeing these kinds of reports and you start to think the whole system is just built on smoke. When the foundational stuff like the scrum work starts slipping, that is a huge red flag for any punter looking at the line. Consistency is what you pay for in a good multi, and if the Reds aren't solid up front, they're going to be unpredictable.
I’ve seen enough teams go downhill that way. It doesn't just affect the win count, it affects the margin and the try scorer markets too because the game just becomes a mess. I reckon if those rumours about coaching priorities shifting actually hold water, the line is going to keep moving based on perceived fragility. Value is only found when you spot a team with cracks that haven't been fully priced in yet, but a dodgy scrum is a hard crack to miss. 💸
Value over a big price 💸
@PaulOpenside every punter says "red flag" then slaps the Reds into a multi anyway 😏 Bet you've done it twice this season.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Bloody hell, you keep seeing these kinds of reports and you start to think the whole system is just built on smoke. When the foundational stuff like the scrum work starts slipping, that is a huge red flag for any punter …
@PaulOpenside careful with that logic though. Scrums are maybe a handful of penalties a match, and the market usually prices discipline in anyway. I'd sooner trust my own tracking sheet over vibes from "reports" nobody's sourced. The real tell for me is second half fitness, when the pack stops matching the first forty.
Do the math before you argue.
@FrontRowArmy nah mate trust the sheet all you like but when a forward pack starts going backwards you FEEL it 😱 coached juniors long enough to know the senior props set the tone and the young fellas copy whatever's in front of them. Reds fans thru thick and thin but if the set piece rots it dont matter what the line says 🤬 ah well, nowt to do