Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:17 pm Log in Sign up
All Blacks

Three wins from three and still nobody agrees on the best XV

ab selection debate General Rugby Talk All Blacks 16 posts Β·2645 views Β·Posted: 10 Oct 2026, 5:29 am Β·Updated: 19 Nov 2026, 4:38 pm
SC ScrumKiwi Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 241 posts 10 Oct 2026, 5:29 am
Three from three and the forum's still arguing about the XV. That tells you everything about the selectors 😏. They'll trot out the same old faces for Scotland on 7 November and only reshuffle when England at Twickenham on the 21st goes sideways. Chur to anyone brave enough to name a bolter before the tour squad drops - go on, I'll even back mine each way πŸ€‘πŸ’Έ
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
ScrumKiwi wrote:
Three from three and the forum's still arguing about the XV. That tells you everything about the selectors 😏. They'll trot out the same old faces for Scotland on 7 November and only reshuffle when England at Twickenham o…
RO RobFirstFive Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 735 posts 10 Oct 2026, 8:41 am
Went back over my spreadsheet from the first three tests last night, and honestly the selectors' picks track the data better than you'd think. Small sample though, wait for Scotland.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAsNZ Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 1015 posts 10 Oct 2026, 11:53 am
Agree with Rob, three tests is a thin sample for settling a XV. That said I've got money on Scotland at the line on the 7th, so the selectors better bring the real XV πŸ˜­πŸ’Έ
All Blacks game moment
Reply Quote
TA Tauranga15 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 402 posts 10 Oct 2026, 12:14 pm
Three wins and we're still debating? Just pick the form boys from Super Rugby and back them all day, eh 😀 Scotland 7 Nov will sort it. Ah well, nowt to do.
Reply Quote
RO RobbedAgainNightmare Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 241 posts 10 Oct 2026, 3:54 pm
Don't laugh, but I'm confused by the "small sample" thing πŸ˜… Three wins, 121-70 scored across them, how is that thin? If the same blokes keep producing in three straight tests, isn't that exactly what form means? Sorry if that's a dumb question, I'm still learning this stuff πŸ™ And SweetAsNZ, if you've got NZ$ on Scotland at the line on the 7th, doesn't that make your "wait for more data" take a bit... convenient? 😏 Genuinely asking, go easy on me.
New here, soaking it up.
Reply Quote
GL GloryDays247 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 296 posts 10 Oct 2026, 5:48 pm
RobbedAgainNightmare, form doesn't survive a spreadsheet mate, it survives Twickenham 😏. Three wins and 121-70 means sweet nothing until the selectors get off the plane at Murrayfield on 7 November and pick actual combinations instead of name brands. I'll put a cheeky few dollars through the TAB on whoever the bolters are, they always surprise the punters, never us 🀑
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
LO LockLegend Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 448 posts 10 Oct 2026, 7:26 pm
Combinations nobody's picked yet? Sure thing, mate, like form survives a plane to Murrayfield 😏 what'd you stake on that line, SweetAs?
All Blacks team
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Reply Quote
NA Napier_Legend1980 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 457 posts 10 Oct 2026, 8:55 pm
LockLegend asking what people stake on form, rich coming from you, mate πŸ˜‚ remind me of your ROI again before you quiz anyone else's tips? For mine RobbedAgainNightmare has a point the rest of you keep dodging. Three straight wins, 121-70 across them, and you lot are still acting like form evaporates the moment a plane leaves Auckland. The selectors have a real window here: Scotland on 7 Nov, Wales a week later, England at Twickenham on the 21st. If a bloke's been producing in three tests, Murrayfield is where he *proves* it's not luck - so pick him and back him, don't hide behind name brands for the first two and panic reshuffle before Twickenham. GloryDays247 talks about combinations like they're carved in stone, but combos get built by playing blokes together, not by protecting reputations 🀑 So put your TAB money where your mouth is and tell us the XV you'd actually run out, Legend. Or is that also a lottery? 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Reply Quote
TR Tryline_Mate Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 640 posts 10 Oct 2026, 9:29 pm
RobbedAgainNightmare you're not wrong tbh, 121-70 in three tests is form no matter how you dress it 😀 but GloryDays247 has a half point, Murrayfield on 7 Nov is a different beast. Still doesn't mean the selectors can't bolt someone in before Twickenham on the 21st. Pick your ignored combo and name it, mate, else it's just noise. Ah well, nowt to do πŸ”₯πŸ™Œ
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
DI DiehardFaithful Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 369 posts 11 Oct 2026, 1:27 am
Coached juniors Saturday arvo and half my boys back the same names the selectors do, habit beats form every time 😀 three wins is three wins, but yeah, Murrayfield on 7 Nov is where combos get sorted, not a spreadsheet... pick the bolters now or Twickenham on the 21st sorts it the hard way, ah well, nowt to do πŸ‰
In the stands since I was a kid.
Reply Quote
JO JohnNapier1976 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 605 posts 11 Oct 2026, 2:55 am
Been in IT support long enough to know habit beats form every time, ask any bloke who's clicked the same dodgy link twice πŸ˜‚ LockLegend still dodging his TAB history tho 🍿
All Blacks fans
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Reply Quote
PA PaulOpenside Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 281 posts 11 Oct 2026, 5:51 am
Bet the form, not the habit - I chucked NZ$20 on the ABs covering the line at Scotland on 7 Nov and the market's already moved my way πŸ˜„ bolters get their shot before Twickenham.
Value over a big price πŸ’Έ
Reply Quote
FU FullbackMate Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 242 posts 11 Oct 2026, 7:18 am
Word going round is the November tour sorts the XV, not the forum 😏 my source won't hold past Murrayfield, 7 Nov. Those who know, know 🀫
Those who know, know.
Reply Quote
DiehardFaithful wrote:
Coached juniors Saturday arvo and half my boys back the same names the selectors do, habit beats form every time 😀 three wins is three wins, but yeah, Murrayfield on 7 Nov is where combos get sorted, not a spreadsheet...…
JO JoshBeliever Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 206 posts 28 Oct 2026, 7:11 pm
@DiehardFaithful that habit thing makes sense to me, kids just want their favourite names in the team πŸ˜… but I'd reckon three wins means the selectors have earned some trust eh? Still don't laugh if I ask, who'd your boys pick that the forum disagrees with? πŸ™‚
Reply Quote
MA MatchdayZone Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 161 posts 7 Nov 2026, 6:02 am
Ha, my juniors pick their favourites too, half of them want names off the telly πŸ˜‚ Trust the selectors for me, 3-0 speaks. Will be at the pub yelling anyway πŸ–€ Get in!
You don't abandon your own.
Reply Quote
PaulOpenside wrote:
Bet the form, not the habit - I chucked NZ$20 on the ABs covering the line at Scotland on 7 Nov and the market's already moved my way πŸ˜„ bolters get their shot before Twickenham.
SC Scrum7 Newcomerβ˜…β˜†β˜†β˜†β˜† Β· 67 posts 19 Nov 2026, 4:38 pm
@PaulOpenside don't laugh but I had to reread that twice, what does "covering the line" actually mean? πŸ™ˆ I only ever chuck NZ$5 on the TAB for fun with the boys before test weeks, never understood the line stuff properly. Maybe I'm wrong but it sounds like you're saying the market agrees with picking on form over the big names? Cos that's sorta what I was thinking too, three wins in a row should shut the "bring back my favourite" crowd up eh πŸ˜… curious if bolters actually get a run before Twickenham though, or if the selectors play it safe until then?
Learn something new every day.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up β€” it's quick.