Time to raid the Crusaders again
Saw a few of the boys at the pub before the Crusaders game and word is one of their tall timber locks is off-contract at season's end. Didn't catch a name, just enough to get the gears turning. Imagine him lining up beside our second row at Mt Smart next year, sure thing, mate? 😏
Here to argue, not to nod along.
😂 no name but I'm already dreaming tbh. Tall timber down south would boss our lineout straight away, who wouldn't want that at Mt Smart? 🙌💪
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Been tracking lock ages and contracts on my own spreadsheet for a couple of seasons now 📊, and I could be wrong, but the tall timber down south is on the wrong side of thirty for a rebuild. We'd be paying top dollar for maybe two decent years. Compare that with what a younger prospect would give us over five, and the maths gets wobbly. Small sample though, since the rumour doesn't even have a name attached. Mean signing if it happened, but I'd temper the pub talk.
Context beats a bare stat.
Wrong side of thirty? He'd still boss our lineout for two seasons and teach our young fellas a thing or two 💪 backing them all day tbh 🔥
Two decent years of lineout dominance might be worth top NZ$ to us, Tauranga, we've never had that luxury. Still, no name, no contract, nothing to argue about yet.
Hype isn't an argument.
Queenstown51, define "worth it" first. Worth it at what price? A bloke the wrong side of thirty on top NZ$ while our young locks sit on the bench learning nothing? I'd rather pay half and give those boys 20 full games. Rob's spreadsheet is the only post in this thread with actual evidence, and until someone drops a name and a contract date, I'm not convinced.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Seen the big fella at every derby the last few years and he's still winning those lineout calls against us, would take him tomorrow 😏 Even Rob's spreadsheet can't argue with that.
Show me your ROI first 😏
RotoruaLoyal has a point - pay half and give the young fellas game time. Mind you, I sat behind the posts at that derby and their lineout picked us apart all night, so I get the appeal.
Coached against that fella's younger brother in the NPC last year and the whole family's got motor 🔥 I'd pay decent NZ$ for a proper lineout general to mentor our young locks, tbh. They'll learn more from a season training with him than 20 games of getting shovelled. You just know Rob's spreadsheet will find a way 😤🙌
You don't abandon your own.
Mate, I've heard this pub rumour before 🤫 Couple of seasons back word going round was another big fella down south was "done and dusted" for us. Even had a mate swear he'd seen the paperwork. Never happened. Half these whispers die the moment someone's agent wants a pay bump.
Would I be stoked to see that lineout general at Mt Smart? In a heartbeat. But those who know, know how these things drag on. Time will tell 😏
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Seen the big fella at every derby the last few years and he's still winning those lineout calls against us, would take him tomorrow 😏 Even Rob's spreadsheet can't argue with that.
@Napier_Legend1980 don't laugh, guys, but I only started watching the derbies properly last season and even I noticed their lineout making ours look like training drills 😅 So if the big fella's been calling those throws for years, yeah, I'd take him too.
My only worry is the same as Wing_Fan says, how do we know this rumour is any more real than the last one? Feels like half these threads get everyone excited and then nothing happens. Would he actually want to come to us at this stage anyway, or is that wishful thinking?
@JohnInvercargill84 don't worry mate, I asked worse when I first turned up here 😅 The lineout thing gets me too — feels like every derby ours just wobbles while theirs looks sorted. Maybe I'm wrong but wouldn't a bloke like that cost proper NZ$ though? 🤔
New here, soaking it up.
Hmm, dumb question maybe, but how much would a lock like that even want at our stage? Would happily chip in a few NZ$ myself if it helped 😅🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Wing_Fan's right, I've counted three "done deals" that evaporated. Trust the ledger until a contract appears, bro.
Context beats a bare stat.
Jokes aside if he does jump ship I'll happily chuck in some NZ$ too 😅 but NickBreakdown's right, seen too many of these "done deals" go cold... ya just know half these rumours come from a bloke's cousin's barber. Ah well, nowt to do but wait and see 🤷
In the stands since I was a kid.
Jokes aside if he does jump ship I'll happily chuck in some NZ$ too 😅 but NickBreakdown's right, seen too many of these "done deals" go cold... ya just know half these rumours come from a bloke's cousin's barber. Ah well…
@DiehardFaithful the cousin's barber line is spot on, that's exactly where half these rumours start 😅 My rule after last season's heartbreak: no multi leg, no wallet. I had NZ$20 riding on one "confirmed" signing being announced and of course it never landed, lesson learned there.
Same energy as a TAB long shot really, fun to dream about but you don't build the weekend around it. When the club actually posts the contract photo, that's when I'd chip in. Until then I'm treating every rumour like a tip from a bloke at the pub who swears he "knows someone". 🍺
Up one week, down the next. Classic.
Cousin's barber 😂 nah heard that one too, half my club trainer reckons he knows everything and he knows nought. Moana pinching a Crusaders lock would be HUGE tho 🔥 ah well, nowt to do but wait 🤷