Which Northland bolter from the Wellington and Waikato wins earns an
Funny how everyone's suddenly an expert the week after Northland put 52 on Wellington away. I was at Semenoff for the Waikato game and that 34:17 wasn't a fluke - they just bullied them up front. But then you look at that Harbour match, 42:57, and the Counties Manukau slip at home, and you've got to wonder which team actually turns up.
My take: the wins are real, the consistency isn't. If there's a bolter worth an All Blacks look it comes out of those two big scalps, because you don't stitch up Waikato and Wellington in back-to-back weeks with muppets. Anyone taking the TAB line on the Southland game though is basically flipping a coin with this lot, feast or famine, hard out. Who's your pick?
Here to argue, not to nod along.
I was at the Harbour game and honestly the 42:57 felt worse than the scoreline, so I'd pump the brakes a bit before booking flights to test matches. Here's my problem with the feast-or-famine read: the wins over Waikato and Wellington came off the back of a bruised pack dominating collisions, while Harbour and Counties Manukau got joy by making Northland defend long sequences. Same team, three weeks, completely different defensive workload. That pattern usually says more about opponents' game plans than about genuine form.
That said, I could be wrong, and the Wellington performance away is the outlier that keeps the bolter conversation alive. Scoring 52 on the road against a side that had been solid tells you something individual guys are standing up. My own table has me tracking tackle-count-to-possession ratios by opponent quality, and the gap between the two win weeks and the two losses is stark.
Context beats a bare stat.
Rob was at the Harbour game, I heard a different story from my source 😏 someone got told at training that win wasn't the worry. Details in the DMs if you're keen.
Those who know, know.
FullbackMate talking about "sources in the DMs" 😱 bro, I was at the Harbour game too, no mystery there, they got smoked up front. Give me a bolter who fronts like the Waikato win, not someone hiding in gossip 🔥
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Not across the training gossip stuff but I'd back what Rob said about Harbour, that one stung watching the highlights, and it makes the Waikato and Wellington wins look more like the pack just turned up those weeks 😅 does anyone actually know if the same forwards fronted against Counties Manukau? That 19:22 home slip is the one I keep coming back to 🤔
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
Chur asked the million dollar question tbh, where was that pack against Counties Manukau? 🤬 I was at the 19:22 slip and they looked flat from the kick-off, no mongrel. That's my caveat with the bolter hype: front like they did against Waikato all season and sure, give the kid a look 🔥 backing them all day either way.
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Flat from kick-off at the Counties game yeah... watched from the couch and they looked like a different side to the one that bullied Waikato the week before 😤 reckon the bolter conversation should go to whoever fronted in BOTH those wins, you just know Ian Foster's mob notice blokes who show up every week, not every second week. Ah well, nowt to do but see how they go against Southland.
In the stands since I was a kid.
DiehardFaithful nailed it, whoever fronted in BOTH those wins earns the look 🔥 coach the juniors here and we harp on consistency every training, no mongrel vs Counties kills any bolter chat tbh
You don't abandon your own.
Nah, luck is just rubbish sometimes. Form wins in the end, ya gotta stay glued to the action! 🏉💪
You don't abandon your own.
Chur StandsGuy_Ultra, consistency wins jerseys 🔥 only caveat: the Harbour hiding showed the pack can get mangled, so bolter's gotta front vs Counties first 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Don't laugh if this is a dumb question, but does a bolter really need the Counties game, or just the two wins? Feels harsh that one flat 19:22 night wipes out bullying Waikato 34:17 and putting 52 on Wellington away 😅 sorry if that's been answered already 🙏
New here, soaking it up.
RobbedAgain, one flat night against Counties shouldn't kill a bolter's chances, but the selectors will remember that 42:57 Harbour hiding more than the flashy wins 😏
Show me your ROI first 😏
Heard similar off a source, that the selectors were more rattled by the Harbour scrum going backwards than impressed by the fancy scorelines 😏 you know the rest. Flashy wins are easy to remember for us punters, coaches remember getting mangled up front. Word going round is the Counties game matters more than the two wins combined, purely because everyone wants to see who fronts when the pack's under the pump. Anyone claiming otherwise hasn't sat through a selection meeting, and I haven't either to be fair 🤫
Solid source, details in the DMs.
So the Harbour scrum was the real problem? That makes sense I guess, coaches would notice that stuff way before us punters do 😅 thanks for explaining Fullback9!