Can Taranaki's 55:19 rout of Southland really push any of our boys
Big one coming our way Saturday π₯ that 55:19 on Southland had me out of my chair tbh β proper statement win at home. Now the question everyone's asking: who from that lot actually earns a Bledisloe look?
Honest take, padding stats against a leaking Southland defence is one thing, doing it against Wellington (even one that got torched 52 by Northland π±) is another. If those boys back it up against real opposition, some selectors have to sit up. And sure, All Blacks spots aren't handed out for one hammering... but a big performance here with the Wallabies tests looming? That's exactly when you want your name loud πͺ backing them all day, through thick and thin. π
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Out of my chair too bro, but one smashed Southland side doesn't put anyone in an All Blacks squad, does it? π€¬ You just know selectors will want to see it against decent oppo, and Wellington getting 52 put on them at home tells you the quality of that fixture was shocking either way. Backing our boys all day Saturday though, then we'll talk Bledisloe π₯ ah well, nowt to do but wait.
Tauranga15's right, Southland are basically a TAB rolling bag of NZ$ losses π anyone look decent against them. If Taranaki put 40 on Wellington Saturday, then I'll start listening π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
I've got Southland's defensive numbers on a spreadsheet somewhere and honestly they made everyone look like George Bridge out there, so I'd pump the brakes on handing out black jerseys off one afternoon π. That said, Tauranga15's half right only, selectors do look at form weeks, and if a couple of Taranaki lads back up 55 points with a real showing against Wellington on the 4th, that's a two-game sample worth talking about. I could be wrong, but I'd rather judge the Hawke's Bay trip first than write anyone off over the quality of the opposition.
Context beats a bare stat.
I watched a bit of that Southland game replay and honestly even I could see the defence was toast π
so yeah, agreed with Tauranga15, one rout doesn't make an All Black. Still learning this NPC-to-ABs ladder thing, but Saturday against Wellington feels like the real test, since they'll actually tackle. If someone goes well in a proper contest then maybe I'd get excited π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Made the trip up for that Southland game and even from the terraces you could see the gaps were huge π
but bro, some of those finishes were pure class, you just know a bloke who does that against toast will back himself against Wellington too πͺ Saturday's the real audition and if we keep it rolling into Hawke's Bay away then selectors gotta look π
You don't abandon your own.
Queenstown_Mad's right that class finishes are class, but I've been burned before loading up on a blowout hero, put $40 on a Southland flogging turning into AB talk last year, didn't land π Saturday against Wellington tells us more.
Nah Rob's got a point, one afternoon of footy against a side that's leaking like Southland doesn't make a black jersey π
but I was watching that game with my old clubmates at the pub and even the crusty forwards were saying some of those finishes looked legit, no defence gives you that kind of footwork on its own. Saturday against Wellington's the real test, you just know our lot never make it easy though π₯πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
MaulTragic's crusty pub forwards are the real selectors here π Same logic burned me backing a blowout hero on the TAB last season. Beat Wellington Saturday and I'll listen π€£
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
MaulTragic's crusty pub forwards are the real selectors here π Same logic burned me backing a blowout hero on the TAB last season. Beat Wellington Saturday and I'll listen π€£
@JohnNapier1976 careful mate, every punter says "beat Wellington and I'll listen" then moves the goalposts when they actually do it π That rout says more about Southland's shambles than Taranaki anyway, it's a lottery trying to read anything into it. Sunday will sort the real ones from the pub talk, and I've already got a few NZ$ saying you'll be quiet regardless π
Show me your ROI first π
Coached juniors Tuesday night and the boys were still buzzing about that Southland rout π
but Sunday's a different beast - Wellington got pumped 52 at home, they'll come here filthy and desperate πͺ backing our lot all day!
Heart with the team, head on pause.
SweetAsNZ's on the money, blowout heroes burn you π A mate of mine down the pub swears a source's already whispering about one Taranaki name, though. Sunday vs a filthy Wellington? Then I'll listen π€«
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Put a tenner on Taranaki -13 before that Southland score even moved the line, and I'd rather back a try scorer in a tight test than a bloke padding up on a leaky defence π
give me one of our boys slicing up a filthy Wellington side Sunday and I'll actually pay for the ABs jersey myself. Blowout heroes landed me nothing last season, value's in Saturday's effort πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
have you seen what the young lot are getting so worked up about these days? everyoneβs fixated on the massive scores and the massive routs, like the southland game, or the huge win against wellington, right? i remember back when we played those big matches down at eden park, we weren't worrying as much about the final score being a bloody blowout. we were watching how hard the lads fought for every single metre, whether they won by seven points or seventy. thatβs the difference. a high score is just numbers on a board, and you can buy a team to run up those scores. but the proper rugby, the kind that sticks with you, that's the bit of dogged effort, the graft, the feeling in your chest when someone just refuses to give up even when they're absolutely hammered. that was the spirit that players like drury carried, not just the tally.
Seen it all, trust me.
Don't laugh but this is genuinely helpful for a new punter like me π
I nearly threw a few dollars at the Taranaki lads after seeing that Southland score, figured a rout must mean something. GloryDays247's point about it just being Southland's shambles kind of clicked for me though.
So what should I actually be watching for in the Wellington game then? Like, is it just about how one player goes against a proper defence, or are there smaller things that tell you more than the scoreboard? Sorry if that's a dumb question, still learning the ropes here π
New here, soaking it up.
Don't laugh but this is genuinely helpful for a new punter like me π
I nearly threw a few dollars at the Taranaki lads after seeing that Southland score, figured a rout must mean something. GloryDays247's point about it β¦
@RobbedAgainNightmare good on you for pausing before throwing the dosh down, young fella, that instinct alone puts you ahead of half the TAB queue. One blowout against a shambles tells you bugger all, seen it all before. Watch how Taranaki travel to Wellington instead, that'll tell you more than any fifty-pointer π
Those score lines against the opposition, they always look a certain way on paper. But I heard word on the grapevine that this whole dynamic is deeper than just a blowout, you know the rest. Things are shifting, and everyone is gonna find out soon. π