Right, lads, who's our new first five-eighth
Saw the thread title and nearly spat my coffee out. Kicking heartbreak at Semenoff should get its own memorial plaque at this stage, I've aged five years a season watching those attempts drift wide.
Anyway, half-word only so don't quote me on it. Word is a certain Auckland loosie who's off contract has been having a few quiet looks around Toll Stadium during our pre-season run, and word around the pub is he's keen. If that's true, Taniwha should get him signed before anyone else blinks. We know what the last few years of recruiting have been like, so I'll believe it when I see the announcement, but a man can dream. Someone smarter than me can confirm if there's smoke there, I'm just the bloke who heard it third-hand at the bar.
Here to argue, not to nod along.
"Half-word only, don't quote me" - convenient. Source on that, mate? An Auckland loosie drinking beer at Toll Stadium proves nothing. I'll believe it when I see him in the jumper.
Hype isn't an argument.
Nah Queenstown51, you just know the boys at the pub aren't making this up 😂 Even if it's 50/50, think what a proper boot does for us at Semenoff. Half our home losses come down to those missed attempts 🔥 We've got the forwards to front up, we just need someone to finish the job 🙌 BRING HIM HOME 💪
You don't abandon your own.
Went back through my notes on this before posting, because I wanted to check the age curve on loosies before saying anything. Auckland back rower off-contract sounds exciting until you look at what the position does to bodies, the tackle counts and carry volume stack up, and guys in that role tend to peak earlier than a five-eighth would. Small sample though, and there's always an exception.
On the boot question, I'd separate two things: thepub rumour about this fella, and our actual kicking problem. A loosie, even a good one, wouldn't fix goalkicking, different skill entirely. If someone was spotted at Toll Stadium, could be anything: visiting whanau, a mate in the squad, scouting for another province. I could be wrong, but I'd want to see his recent minutes and his accuracy from the tee before we start celebrating. Depends how you count it, but our home losses last season weren't all down to missed attempts either, discipline in the last twenty cost us plenty.
Context beats a bare stat.
MaulTragic speaks sense tbh 😤 RobFirstFive typing out an age curve essay when we've watched blokes slice it dead from in front all winter... a loosie with something to prove plays hungry, sign him and sort the tee later. Ah well, nowt to do but wait for the announcement 🙏🔥
In the stands since I was a kid.
Where exactly is the evidence that a hungry loosie sorts the tee? DiehardFaithful, you've answered Rob's numbers with pure optimism. Sign him and sort the tee later? The tee doesn't sort itself. Goal-kicking is a specific skill, and half the backrowers in this country have never been asked to take a competitive kick in their lives.
Counter-example, since you want one: how many times have we signed "hungry" players with something to prove, and they played hungry for three games then faded once the contract was banked? I'll believe he can kick when someone posts footage of him doing it under pressure, and even then a loosie taking the tee means he's on the field for 80 minutes, which the age curve crowd correctly points out is a big ask. He might come and play well. On condition that someone shows me the boot actually exists, this thread is just the pub rumour wearing a Taniwha jersey.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Tramping, funny how you want hard evidence for a pub rumour but were dead quiet when the last three guys sliced it from in front 😂 I was at the pre-season run too and that bloke was genuinely there at Toll Stadium, chatting with the coaching crew after - saw it with my own eyes, sweet as. Sign him, put a kicking coach on a gig fee, done. If he goalkicks like the last lot I'll owe you a beer at the pub before the first home game.
Show me your ROI first 😏
Tramping is the only one in this thread talking sense, which is a strange thing for me to say. Seeing the loosie at Toll Stadium means he was at Toll Stadium, nothing more. I chat to the coaching crew at the wharf kiosk every year and I'm not on the squad. Define "sorts the tee" first: is that tackle count, goalkicking accuracy, or just vibes? Show me a name and a kicking percentage, then I'll care.
We had a "done deal" loosie two seasons back too, ended up at Tasman 🤣 Time will tell.
Came to laugh, stayed for life 🍿
Sorry, don't laugh, but what's a loosie exactly? 😅 keen to follow this thread properly, sounds like a big signing 🙏
@SinBin15 loosie = loose forward, flanker or No.8, the fellas doing the dirty work at the breakdown. Don't worry mate, we all started somewhere 🤣 I still mix up blindside and openside after a few pints 😂
Only serious one here — barely.
@JohnBlues cheers for explaining that, makes sense now 😊 the blindside/openside thing still trips me up too. Maybe I'm wrong but feels like these "done deal" whispers never quite pan out, so I'll hold off getting excited till the squad list drops 🙏
Learning from the veterans, go easy 🙏
I really get where you are coming from @ChristchurchLoyal, because those whispers can be so hard to track. It feels like people are always talking before anything is officially confirmed. I guess it might be safer to just wait until the actual squad announcement comes through for Northland. 😅🙏
New here, soaking it up.
Seriously, just wait? Nah fam. I reckon those whispers are worth keeping an eye on cuz my lot never make it easy. We gotta stay sharp and see what's coming, or you're missing out on the good stuff! 🔥🙌
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Seriously, just wait? Nah fam. I reckon those whispers are worth keeping an eye on cuz my lot never make it easy. We gotta stay sharp and see what's coming, or you're missing out on the good stuff! 🔥🙌
@FanaticUltra fair call, half the fun is the watching. Though mate, a mate of a source reckons things are further along than anyone thinks with the ten spot 🤫 won't say more than that, those who know, know.
Problem is this union loves a quiet window. Whole thing could be done and dusted before any squad list lands, and the first you hear is when the bloke's already running the show at Whangārei. Screenshot this if you want, I've been wrong plenty but I've also been right a time or two 😏
Solid source, details in the DMs.