Semenoff Stadium's hill beats any fancy corporate seat in the
Watched too many of you lot drool over the new covered seating at Eden Park and forgot where you actually come from π€‘
That western hill in the 2022 semi was the best twenty bucks anyone ever spent at a game. Whole bank of us singing, sun going down, and I got my beer back before the second half kicked off. Ten minutes flat. Go try that at some glass-and-steel stadium where a pie costs NZ$9 and some suit tells you to sit down. Half this forum wouldn't last a Bunnings NPC round on the terraces, too busy picking out the exact angle for their story posts. Fancy seats are for people who watch rugby like a spreadsheet. The hill's where the team can actually hear you, and deep down everyone arguing the opposite knows it π
Any stat can be bent.
Twenty bucks for the hill was alright, but the beer queue was ten minutes because the bar ran out, mate. I was in it.
Bar ran out cos 500 of us drank it dry π± that's a badge of honour mate. Western hill singing itself hoarse, best NZ$20 ever. Ah well, nowt to do, see yous on the grass π₯π
In the stands since I was a kid.
Tryline's got the run of it I reckon. Depends how you count it, but a bar going dry because half the western hill drank it flat is demand, not supply failure, and that queue held at ten minutes anyway. You pay NZ$20 at Eden Park for a covered seat and you get silence and a waitress. Give me 500 thirsty mates on grass every time π
Context beats a bare stat.
The bar going dry mid-song and nobody complaining, that's when you know you're at a real occasion π I've been watching Test footy since the amateur days and that western hill in 2022 ranks up with the old Eden Park nights for atmosphere. Young fellas today want a roof and a screen, good luck to them, but NZ$20 on the grass with a hoarse voice Monday morning beats a waitress every time.
Ha, SweetAs, the amateur days card gets played every time on this forum π Look, I love a good reminisce as much as anyone but the old Eden Park nights had forty thousand voices doing the job, the hill had a few hundred singing into a half-empty bourbon supply. Different animal entirely.
Still reckon the hill wins though. NZ$20, your own patch of grass, nobody telling you to sit down, and that 2022 semi noise carried right over the Shed. My knees would trade it all for a covered seat these days, but the heart says grass. Ah well, we'll see what the boss says when I suggest standing up for eighty minutes in winter π
Been here longer than some have followed.
ClassicFan, voices per head still beats an empty corporate bowl. Hundred on the hill singing beats ten thousand politely clapping, and I'll believe any seat beats it when I see it.
Sample first, conclusions after.
RotoruaLoyal's got it right as far as I'm concerned, though I'd add one caveat, the hill needs numbers to work its magic. I keep my own notes every round and the 2022 semi crowd against the quiet covered bowls I've sat in elsewhere isn't even a contest, but I could be wrong about whether a few hundred would've carried it on a cold Wednesday night. Still, NZ$20 and ten minutes for a beer, nobody's beaten that value since.
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how ClassicFan suddenly needs forty thousand voices before he'll admit a hill works π Mate you can have your cushioned seat and your forty thousand whispers, I'll take the western side any day. And RobFirstFive talking about needing numbers, did you see the beer line in 2022? Ten minutes flat with half the town on that grass. Try getting a schooner at one of those corporate bowls in under half an hour, laughable really.
Here's my awkward question for the seat fanciers, since we're being honest about records. When's the last time a covered seat made you hug a stranger after the final whistle? Mine was on that hill and I still can't remember who the bloke was π€‘ Sad truth is some of you would trade the lot for a roof and a lanyard. Not me, thanks.
Any stat can be bent.
My old man reckons you can measure a ground by how long the singing lasts after the whistle, and by that yardstick the western hill in 2022 beat Eden Park on any night I've sat through there. The beer line at ten minutes flat is my whole argument in one stat, FrontRow. I could be wrong, but ClassicFan's forty thousand whispers versus a few hundred hill voices still feels like an open fight to me.
Beer line at ten minutes flat, that's a hard stat to argue with π Only ground I've been to where I'd happily lose the first quarter queueing. If anyone was taking odds on hill vs corporate bowl I'd have loaded up on the hill, landed every time I've sat on it.
My old man reckons you can measure a ground by how long the singing lasts after the whistle, and by that yardstick the western hill in 2022 beat Eden Park on any night I've sat through there. The beer line at ten minutesβ¦
@Ruck9 the singing test is a good one, my old man swears by something similar π Only knock I'd give the hill is from a punter's view, you can't see the clock properly from some spots up there, cost me a try scorer leg once when I didn't realise the timeframe had drifted. Still worth it though, that crowd noise carries unlike anywhere I've sat in a bowl.
Value over a big price πΈ