What is the TMO and why does the ref still get the final say?
Hi everyone, don't laugh but what even is the TMO? ๐ I keep hearing the commentators say "ref, check with the TMO" when a try looks iffy, and I genuinely can't work out if the ref can ignore what the TMO says or not? Help me out please ๐
No question's silly, mate, we all started somewhere. The TMO is the fella up in the box watching replays; the ref calls on him for tries or foul play he's unsure about, gets the advice, then makes his own call on the field. Back in the day we just had the touch judges and a prayer, so think of the TMO as a second pair of eyes, good as gold, but the whistle stays with the ref ๐
Seen it all, trust me.
Thanks John_Faithful790 ๐ So if the TMO says no try but the ref reckons otherwise, can he still award it? Or does the advice always win? Still learning this, don't laugh ๐
Learn something new every day.
Yeah the ref can still award it, TMO only advises. He's the one with the whistle, if he reckons the replay doesn't prove anything either way he'll go with his on-field read. Think of it like a line moving then the final price getting set at kick-off, the advice informs the call but the ref signs it off.
Value over a big price ๐ธ
Good question from BachMate, and Paul's spot on. The ref only goes with the TMO's advice when the replay actually proves something one way or the other. No conclusive footage, on-field decision stands, that's the rule.ๅฎ็จ tip for punters like me: don't try to out-guess these calls on a multi, the odd try scorer leg can die on a TMO frame-by-frame and there's no way to price that. I've had a NZ$20 payout turn on a bootlace in goal. ๐ญ
Thanks John_Faithful790 ๐ So if the TMO says no try but the ref reckons otherwise, can he still award it? Or does the advice always win? Still learning this, don't laugh ๐
Ah that actually clicks now, thanks guys ๐
So "conclusive" is doing a lot of heavy lifting there. Wonder how the ref decides what counts as conclusive when the angles all disagree?
Learn something new every day.
Good question from BachMate, and Paul's spot on. The ref only goes with the TMO's advice when the replay actually proves something one way or the other. No conclusive footage, on-field decision stands, that's the rule.ๅฎ็จโฆ
Yeah, it's the rules, I guess, but how often are those on-field calls just pure eyeball stuff? ๐ฉ Sometimes the TMO sees something the ref can't catch with a split second of vision, even if it isn't 'conclusive' enough by the book. Still feels like we need less rules and more passion out there! ๐ฅ
Good question from BachMate, and Paul's spot on. The ref only goes with the TMO's advice when the replay actually proves something one way or the other. No conclusive footage, on-field decision stands, that's the rule.ๅฎ็จโฆ
@SweetAsNZ spot on with the rule, but "conclusive" is doing exactly what Scrum7 says, all the heavy lifting. A source of mine who's been involved at provincial level reckons the refs get told in training that if they'd whistle it live, they back themselves unless the footage screams otherwise. Screen shows them an angle or two, not every angle, and the TMO picks what gets shown. So yeah, half the time it's a feel thing dressed up as process ๐
Word going round is the angle selection matters more than the check itself, but you know the rest. ๐คซ
Solid source, details in the DMs.