Can Manawatu's win over Auckland shake up the All Blacks debate?
40 on Auckland away and suddenly every punter with a TAB account reckons they know the next All Blacks squad π€‘. Sure thing, mate, one good night changes everything and in reality Canterbury sneaked past Harbour by a single point - hardly world beaters coming to Palmerston North. Should be a proper crack on 3 October either way π
Here to argue, not to nod along.
One night does change things when you're a Turbo, LockLegend π€ 40 on Auckland away after pushing Waikato hard, selectors watching, bet they are π₯πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Selectors picking off one 40-pointer vs a loss to Waikato a week earlier? Sweet as logic, FanaticUltra π Anyone actually put money on the Turbos yet or is everyone just talking? Remind me of your ROI?
Show me your ROI first π
Watched the Auckland game tape twice now and the thing that struck me wasn't the 40, it was the shape of it - Manawatu scored in bursts while Auckland were still chasing structure, which flatters the margin a bit. Compare that with Waikato a week earlier where the same attack managed 27 and the defence leaked 36. Two very different nights, one sample of two games. I could be wrong, but I'd want to see how they handle Canterbury's set piece before crowning anyone.
On the selection angle, both sides have merit. LockLegend is right that a one-point squeak over Harbour isn't scary form, but Canterbury also put 34 on Southland comfortably, so they're trending up too. I'd frame it as: Auckland were loose and got punished, Canterbury won't be. If a Turbo still plays well against a sharper opposition in front of the selectors on 3 October, that tells us far more than the Auckland fireworks did. Depends how you count it, really - points scored or quality of opponent.
Context beats a bare stat.
Right with RobFirstFive here, bursts made that 40 look prettier than the play did. Line will likely tighten towards Canterbury anyway, I'm holding my $20 until match eve πΈ
Bursts or not, 40 away at Eden Park doesn't happen by accident π€ Canterbury needed a last-gasp Harbour escape, our lot never make it easy. 3 Oct gonna be massive π₯πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
I'm new here so forgive the dumb question π
but StandsGuyLoyal sounds right β 40 at Eden Park surely counts for something, even if it came in bursts? If we get close to Canterbury I'd reckon selectors have to peek.
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
Chur welcome aboard π nah that 40 was earned, I was there yelling at the telly the whole way, and dont forget they pushed Waikato hard the week before too, so this isnt one good night. selectors peeking? you just know they are π₯ ah well, nowt to do till 3 Oct πͺ
Agree with Tauranga15, the Waikato loss wasn't a hiding either π but one tight defeat plus one win won't jump anyone ahead of proven test playersβ¦ probably asking because still learning how NPC form weighs up π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Coached juniors with a few Turbos fans here and they've been buzzing since Eden Park π
but Wellington_15 has a point, selectors want form week after week, not two games. 3 Oct will tell us plenty π€¬π₯
You don't abandon your own.
Was still paying off my $20 TAB loss on that Waikato game when the Turbos went and dropped 40 on Auckland π€£ agree with Tauranga15 though. Two good weeks, selectors will notice.
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Chur Tauranga15, felt the same yelling at my telly up here π€¬ tho tbh I've watched our lot never make it easy, leading Auckland then nearly coughing it back shows the gap to test level is still there. Canterbury scraping past Harbour by one then handling Southland properly, that's a side that wins ugly when it counts. 3 Oct at home, juniors and me are already planning the trip down π₯πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Chur Tauranga15, felt the same yelling at my telly up here π€¬ tho tbh I've watched our lot never make it easy, leading Auckland then nearly coughing it back shows the gap to test level is still there. Canterbury scraping β¦
@StandsGuy_Ultra1997 had my multi on the Turbos line that night, near coughed it back but landed πΈ nearly grey. Selectors won't care, they want 80 minutes every week. π₯
Value over a big price πΈ
@StandsGuy_Ultra1997 had my multi on the Turbos line that night, near coughed it back but landed πΈ nearly grey. Selectors won't care, they want 80 minutes every week. π₯
@PaulOpenside mate I was sweating that same multi, had a few NZ$ on the Turbos and nearly chucked the remote at the telly when they let Auckland back in π± fair dinkum the heart rate was up. selectors do want the 80 minutes tho... but that middle-20 defence was proper test standard, ah well, nowt to do π€¬π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
Agree with Queenstown_Mad, one hot night doesn't move the needle much π
I only started following the NPC properly this year so maybe I'm wrong, but does consistency really beat one big game for selectors?
New here, soaking it up.
Saw it live at the pub with a few Turbos boys, and tbh the defenceline up the middle that night looked test-ready πͺ being honest tho, they let 34 back on Auckland after dominating, so it's the last 20 minutes vs Canterbury that'll sort the fern-wearers from the flash. consistency wins, always has π€¬π₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
Metric_Lab makes my point for me without realising it, conceded 34 after being well on top, and the week before that leaked 36 to Waikato. Selectors don't grade highlights reels. Nick, to answer your question directly: yes, consistency beats one big night, every time. It has to. Otherwise every roster would be built off six-day form and gut feel, which is just laziness with a nicer name.
So my verdict on the "shaping the silver fern" angle? I'll believe it when I see it. Canterbury edged Harbour by one and beat Southland comfortably, that's two different kinds of wins, which tells you more about a squad than one fireworks display does. If a Turbos forward holds his structure for 80 minutes against Canterbury's pack on 3 October, fair enough, put him in the conversation. Until then this is a good NPC fixture, nothing more. Happy to be proven wrong at Palmerston North.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Metric_Lab makes my point for me without realising it, conceded 34 after being well on top, and the week before that leaked 36 to Waikato. Selectors don't grade highlights reels. Nick, to answer your question directly: yβ¦
@RotoruaLoyal fair point on the leaks, but you're picking on the Turbos when half the country concedes junk points in that comp tbh π€ selectors watched that middle 60 and so did I, looked test-ready up the guts π₯ consistency matters sure, but one bloke smashing tackles at 12 for 60 minutes beats four average weeks every day of the week πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.
Harry, one good hour proves nothing. I've watched blokes tear up the NPC then drown at test level for a decade. Selectors know the difference, and 34 conceded says plenty.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@StandsGuy_Ultra1997 had my multi on the Turbos line that night, near coughed it back but landed πΈ nearly grey. Selectors won't care, they want 80 minutes every week. π₯
@PaulOpenside nah the selectors would've clocked that middle 60, that's all they need tbh π₯ every punter going grey over a multi forgets the actual footy on show. You just know Razor's staff had someone at that game with a notebook out
You don't abandon your own.