Can someone explain what a scrum actually is, don't laugh please?
Hi all, hope this is the right place for a dumb question π. Been watching a bit of Bunnings NPC with my flatmates and every time someone knocks the ball on, play stops and everyone packs down in that huddle thing, and I genuinely don't get it. What even is a scrum for, and why don't they just let play keep going? Don't laugh please π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
No dumb question at all mate, we all started somewhere π The scrum's just the restart after a small stuff-up like a knock-on: eight forwards from each side bind together and push against each other while the halfback feeds the ball into the middle, and whichever pack shoves the other off the ball gets to hook it back. Back in the day at Eden Park you'd watch a good pack just milk penalties out of the push, so no laughs here, that huddle thing wins games.
Seen it all, trust me.
Cheers for explaining John, that actually helped π
Quick follow up though, sorry if this is silly: so when the halfback feeds the ball in, can he just sneak it to his own side's side, or does the ref make him put it straight down the middle? Still learning all this π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Yeah the law says straight down the tunnel, but in practice the halfback wheels it in toward his own second row most of the time and refs rarely ping it. That's why the feed matters as much as the push, the pack that gets the ball fed to their side almost always wins it. Watch a few scrums closely and you'll see it, then the shoving decides who actually comes out with the ball when the feed's tight πΈ
@SweetAsNZ spot on tbh, coached the juniors and I still see our halfback wheel it every single time π ref just lets it slide unless someone gets pumped at the push... honestly think a crooked feed is part of the game now, you just know which pack's gonna get the ball before it even goes in. Ah well, nowt to do π
In the stands since I was a kid.
SweetAs nailed it, the feed is half the battle. From a punting view that's why scrum penalties and turnover momentum swing lines late, worth remembering if you ever put a match in a TAB multi. Also steered many a first-five's day. Keep the questions coming Steve, none of this is silly πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
@Supporter_Life the feed decides most scrums, sure, but "swing lines late" is doing a lot of work there. Receipts please. Which matches actually moved on a scrum penalty?
Sample first, conclusions after.
The feed's been crooked for years and everyone just shrugs π watched enough scrums from the touchline at McLean Park to know the ref only blows it when he feels like it. Word going round is the law might get tightened up properly one day, but I'll believe it when I see it π€«
Those who know, know.
The feed's been crooked for years and everyone just shrugs π watched enough scrums from the touchline at McLean Park to know the ref only blows it when he feels like it. Word going round is the law might get tightened upβ¦
@FullbackMate so the evidence is "I watched from the touchline and refs have vibes"? That's exactly my point. Every ref handles feeds differently, some let the halfback drop it in at second receiver depth, others actually care. If the law gets tightened I'll believe it when I see it, until then it's just feel, and feel is a poor substitute for a ruling.
Hype isn't an argument.