Can someone explain what a scrum actually is, in plain words?
Okay don't laugh at me, but I read the first post and I'm still stuck on the hooker bit π
Is he actually hooking the ball back with his foot when it comes in, or is that just what the position is called? Like does he strike it or just wait for the push to do the work? Help me out, I'm from Gisborne so I should probably know this by now π cheers!
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Not a dumb question at all Steve, the hooker one trips up plenty of new heads π Yes, the name is literal. He genuinely strikes the ball back with his foot when it comes into the tunnel, that's the "hook". The props either side are there to hold him steady while he does it, and if the pack's going backwards the whole thing falls apart because you can't strike a ball that's already past your boots. That's why a good hooker is worth his weight to his forwards.
Why a reset instead of a free pass?_word going round the pub is that a scrum keeps the contest honest, knock-on gives the other pack a chance to pinch the ball off you, which is half the fun of the game. Careful with the crouch-bind-set call, it happens fast, then feed. As for collapses, nah, they're not mucking about - front rows genuinely cop a tonne of force, so a dobber referee blows it up for safety till it's stable. As for having a flutter, stick to TAB only and keep your NZ$ small, mate.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
Thanks Chris, that actually helps π
So if the hooker just needs the right foot at the right moment, does the team putting the ball in have an advantage? Seems unfair otherwise π€
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
Yes, Chur, that's exactly it, the team putting the ball in gets the advantage, which is the whole point of the scrum as a restart. It's meant to be a controlled contest, not a 50/50 raffle: feed the ball in, your hooker gets first strike. In theory the feed has to be straight down the tunnel and hookers do compete, but a crooked feed goes unnoticed so often you can basically assume the side with the put-in wins their own ball. Watch a few Bunnings NPC scrums with that in mind and it'll click quick.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Yes, Chur, that's exactly it, the team putting the ball in gets the advantage, which is the whole point of the scrum as a restart. It's meant to be a controlled contest, not a 50/50 raffle: feed the ball in, your hooker β¦
@RotoruaLoyal cheers, that clears it up heaps for me π
don't laugh guys, I only realised last season the hooker actually hooks it with his foot. Still learning this! π
Learn something new every day.
Not dumb at all, half the pub couldn't tell you either. Yeah Chur, feed's supposed to go straight down the tunnel but in practice the halfback shovels it towards his own hooker's boot, so the "advantage" is bigger than it looks on paper. Watch that at the game before you put anything on. A scrum going backwards on its own ball is a killer, and that's the sort of thing that swings a line late.
Value over a big price πΈ
Cheers, got it now. So the halfback basically cheats the feed in, meaning the "advantage" is way bigger than the rulebook says π
Maybe I'm wrong but that feels worth watching before I put NZ$ on anything at the TAB?
New here, soaking it up.
Chur Jackal, nailed it. Watch a couple of resets before you touch a punty market - teams that keep losing their own feed get shunted backwards, and that's free metres plus penalties against them. Put NZ$5 on first scrum penalty at the TAB if they offer it, worst case you learn something at the pub πΊ
Value over a big price πΈ
@PaulOpenside Chur for that, coached the juniors' front row for years and still can't pick a scrum penalty live π
NZ$5 at the TAB beats learning at full price tho, get in! πͺπ₯
One love, one side β€οΈ
@BachMate nah no laughing, we've all been there π I coached juniors who thought the same. Wait till you see a tighthead live, whole front row lifting like a wave π
@MatchdayZone the wave description is fair, though I'd add a caveat: half the tightheads you see flagged live are technique penalties, not power ones. Refs call what they can see from one angle. As an accountant I'll happily admit the scrum is the one area of the game where my spreadsheet instincts completely fail me.
Hype isn't an argument.
Chur StandsGuy, glad there's another junior coach in here π I copped a front-row education the hard way back when I played prop in my thirties, got shunted back about ten metres once and the ref just smiled at me π± π
BachMate you'll get it, watch a few games and suddenly the whole front row wrestling match makes sense. Ah well, nowt to do but keep learning eh π₯πͺ
In the stands since I was a kid.