Guys, what actually is a scrum and why do they push like that?
Don't laugh guys but I've watched rugby my whole life and still can't really explain scrums to my mates π
I get it happens after a knock-on or something, but the crouching and pushing bit confuses me. How does the push actually decide who gets the ball? Go easy on me π
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
Nothing to be embarrassed about mate, half the crowd at the pub couldn't explain it either. When someone knocks the ball on, play stops and the two packs bind up and shove against each other, and the team that didn't muck up gets to feed the ball into the middle, so they've already got the head start. Your hooker then hooks it back with his foot while everyone pushes. Back in the day I watched Sean Fitzpatrick's packs just walk the other lot backwards, and once you see that it clicks, the push is basically about shoving the opposition off the ball so your bloke can win it clean.
Seen it all, trust me.
So the team that gets the ball fed in usually wins it too? Sounds almost decided before the push, maybe I'm wrong π
New here, soaking it up.
Good question Nick, and John's got it right so far. The team feeding the ball does hold the advantage because their hooker can strike it the moment it hits the tunnel, but the push still matters, since if the other pack shoves them backwards off the ball or collapses the whole thing, possession can turn over. I could be wrong, but think of it like a tussle at the front of a queue, one bloke starts with his hand on the prize, the rest still have to hold their ground. Watch a couple of scrums where the feed goes crooked and you'll see why it's not a foregone conclusion.
I'd temper that a bit, Ruck9, the feed advantage isn't as automatic as everyone here is making out. Depends how you count it, but plenty of scrums get won against the feed when the pack shoves on the hit and the halfback's put under pressure before the ball's even struck. Nick, watch the Tighthead side's push on the engage, that's where most turnovers actually come from. Small sample though, could be wrong.
Context beats a bare stat.
Good question Nick, and John's got it right so far. The team feeding the ball does hold the advantage because their hooker can strike it the moment it hits the tunnel, but the push still matters, since if the other pack β¦
@RobFirstFive spot on mate π₯ coached the juniors for years and the hit shove wins it way more than the feed. Get your pack going forward on the set and the other halfback's catching a wobbly ball under pressure, ah well, nowt to do πͺ
Watch a few scrums just at the front row and it clicks. Eight forwards bind, three each side at the front, they crouch, bind, then the ref calls "set" and they shove. Halfback throws the ball into the middle tunnel and the hookers stick a leg out to hook it back. Team that got fed in has the head start, like everyone said, but a pack that hits hard and low can shunt them backwards and turn the ball over anyway. Happens more than you'd think.
Practical tip from someone who's paid for this lesson: for a beginner just watch who gets the put-in after each knock-on, that's the easy part. The pushing matters because a dominant scrum either wins you the ball against the feed or wins a penalty when the other lot collapse. And if you ever have a flutter with the TAB, don't touch obscure scrum markets till you've watched a season of them, learned that the hard way with a NZ$20 multi that didn't land π
Value over a big price πΈ
I'd temper that a bit, Ruck9, the feed advantage isn't as automatic as everyone here is making out. Depends how you count it, but plenty of scrums get won against the feed when the pack shoves on the hit and the halfbackβ¦
@RobFirstFive 100% this π coaching the juniors I drill it into them constantly, a good hit shove wins you more against-the-feed ball than any fancy hooker strike. You just know when the oppo front row gets shoved straight up in the air it's panic time for their halfback π±
Also Nick, nah don't stress, most newbies think the feed decides it too. Our lot never make it easy anyway, we'd rather win it the hard way π₯πͺ
You don't abandon your own.