Semenoff Stadium on a wet Whangarei evening is worth more to
Give me a mudbath at Semenoff over any $150k flash import, every day of the week π Round one the fancy backline looked like Bambi on ice while our boys just rolled their sleeves up and got it done. Luck? Nah, that was Taniwha blue earning it. Any punter who backed the visitors that night got what they deserved π
Show me your ROI first π
One wet night in round one and suddenly the whole recruitment strategy is settled? That's a sample size of exactly one match, Kiwi. The same visiting backline would have carved us up on a dry track at Semenoff, and we all know it. Conditions flattered us that evening.
Sounds good but it doesn't survive five minutes of thinking. A decent NZ$150k import who can actually catch and pass would have been handy in every other round of the season, not just the one where the puddles did the defending for us. Grounding out a win in the mud is great, I was there and I loved it, but if the plan is hoping for rain every second Friday I'll need a bit more than one highlight before I buy in.
Sample first, conclusions after.
Rotorua mate, one good dry night doesn't buy you heart in the puddles π₯ our boys ground that win out fair and square, Taniwha blue all day πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
I could be wrong, but I'd back Kiwi's read here. RotoruaLoyal, you're right that one round one is a thin sample, yet context matters: the visitors couldn't even hold shape in the conditions that Semenoff serves up half the season, and that tells you something about squad build the spreadsheet misses. A dry night would be a different game, sure, but we don't get many of those on a Whangarei evening, so I'd rather have the fifty blokes who win in the puddles.
Saw worse nights at old Whangarei grounds in the amateur days, and the tough buggers always won. Weather is a squad-builder, RotoruaLoyal π
Seen it all, trust me.
Funny how everyone quotes the round one mudbath but nobody mentions training Tuesdays at Semenoff when the drains give up. I've stood on the embankment in June watching our forwards work on their scrum machine while the puddles sat there like small lakes. That's the part a $150k import never signs up for.
RotoruaLoyal, fair point on the sample size, honestly. But the visitors knew the forecast too and turned up with a squad built for dry turf. You can call that luck if you want. I call it recruitment that ignored the ground we actually play on. Ask any punter who backed us that night, the line was there for a reason.
Watched our forwards train in exactly those lakes back in June, Supporter88. That's the point though, they adapt while imports slide. Small sample though, one wet win.
Context beats a bare stat.
Took the TAB line on us grinding out wet ones twice already this season, easy NZ$ π Any import who can't handle a puddle can stay home. Chur boys.
Show me your ROI first π
Nah one wet win proves nothing, boys π I was on the embankment too, we got bailed out by their handling errors more than our scrum machine. Ask me again after a dry night πͺ
You don't abandon your own.
Dry night? Their flash backs would still slide around mate, you just know it πͺ Semenoff in the wet is our twelfth man, through thick and thin ππ₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Fun one to chew on, and the honest answer sits somewhere in the middle. One mudbath win plus a couple of TAB lines is a small sample, so I'd want a dry night at Semenoff before crowning the puddles as our twelfth man. Still, watching that flash backline skate around while our pack kept the ball tight told me plenty. Ask me again in round twelve and I'll give you a proper verdict π
Numbers > vibes.
@SweetAsNZ the dropped ball over the line is the perfect example. Everyone remembers the pick-up and drives, nobody remembers the 20 times the conditions turned a scoring chance into a brain fade. One wet game at Semenofβ¦
@Tighthead fair point, one slippery night is a small sample alright π€£ I was at Semenoff for a muddy club final years back and slid my own arse into the car park before kickoff, so the puddles get my vote regardless. Gonna be a fun night when they finally test it dry π
Hold my pint.
Took the TAB line on us grinding out wet ones twice already this season, easy NZ$ π Any import who can't handle a puddle can stay home. Chur boys.
@GloryDays247 easy NZ$ only counts if it lands mate, I've been stung by a late wet-weather try enough times to know. I took the same line once and watched a fullback drop it over the line in the mud, lesson learned. Small stakes for me until the line holds up on a dry night too πΊ
@GloryDays247 easy NZ$ only counts if it lands mate, I've been stung by a late wet-weather try enough times to know. I took the same line once and watched a fullback drop it over the line in the mud, lesson learned. Smalβ¦
@SweetAsNZ the dropped ball over the line is the perfect example. Everyone remembers the pick-up and drives, nobody remembers the 20 times the conditions turned a scoring chance into a brain fade. One wet game at Semenoff and suddenly the puddles are a tactical asset.
I'll take Tighthead's side of this. Before anyone crowns the wet weather as our twelfth man I want the same fixture on a dry track. If the forwards still boss it and the backs hold shape, then the case is real. If it all falls apart on turf, we've learned the win was the other mob's handling errors wearing our colours. Gut feel about the mud is exactly the sort of thing people use to skip the work of checking. Receipts please, then I'll listen.
Sample first, conclusions after.