Tin Hearth
22 Nov, 7:36 pm Log in Sign up
What is a penalty kick and how is it decided?

What is a penalty kick and how is it decided?

explainer New to Rugby 8 posts ·23 views ·Posted: 31 Oct 2026, 8:46 pm ·Updated: 11 Nov 2026, 2:15 am
WE Wellington_15 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 394 posts 31 Oct 2026, 8:46 pm
Can someone explain simply how a penalty kick works? 😅 I keep watching games and the ref gives a penalty, then sometimes the team has a shot at goal, sometimes they kick it out for a lineout, and other times they just tap and go. Don't laugh, but I don't get when they're allowed to pick which one. Still learning this, sorry if it's a dumb question 🙏
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Reply Quote
CL ClassicFan Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 485 posts 31 Oct 2026, 9:38 pm
No laugh from me, we all started somewhere 😄 The ref gives a penalty for a serious infringement and the offended side gets the choice, every time: have a shot at goal for 3 points, kick to touch for an attacking lineout, or tap and go (or take a scrum) if they want to keep the pressure on. It's always their call, and it depends on the score, the field position and the weather more than anything. Back in the day at Athletic Park you'd kick for touch in the slop and go for goal on a fine night, and honestly not much has changed. Ah well, we'll see how quickly it clicks for you.
What is a penalty kick and how is it decided? fans
Been here longer than some have followed.
Reply Quote
JO JoshBeliever Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 206 posts 1 Nov 2026, 11:48 am
Ohh so the attacking team always gets to pick? That makes sense now, thanks ClassicFan 😄 But what if you tap and go and mess it up, do you lose the penalty altogether?
Reply Quote
NickBreakdown1982 wrote:
Honestly, I think the confusion comes from treating the penalty as just a consequence, when it's really an operational decision for the attacking team. If you're watching a set piece and the ref issues a penalty after a …
JA JandalLocal698 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 31 posts 11 Nov 2026, 2:15 am
It’s less about losing the penalty entirely, mate, that’s too simple an explanation. You’re looking at the whole plan going south, which is a different sort of trouble. There’s always a choice when the ref blows the whistle, you know? Whether you're thinking about the immediate points or the game state, the risk of picking the wrong option is what they worry about. Word going around suggests the pressure on those making the call is heavier than most folks realise, especially if the source isn't happy with where the momentum is at. Sometimes the risk of the tap and go being disrupted isn't just tactical, it’s what defines the whole set piece. 🤔🤫
Screenshot this.
Reply Quote
JandalLocal698 wrote:
It’s less about losing the penalty entirely, mate, that’s too simple an explanation. You’re looking at the whole plan going south, which is a different sort of trouble. There’s always a choice when the ref blows the whi…
PA PaulOpenside Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 281 posts 11 Nov 2026, 2:15 am
Fair point Jandal, a botched tap costs you momentum too, not just the shot. Seen blokes burn a certain three that way. That's why I take the points at goal every time 🍺
What is a penalty kick and how is it decided? fans
Value over a big price 💸
Reply Quote
NI NickBreakdown1982 Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 283 posts 1 Nov 2026, 11:18 am
Honestly, I think the confusion comes from treating the penalty as just a consequence, when it's really an operational decision for the attacking team. If you're watching a set piece and the ref issues a penalty after a foul, the attacking team gets to choose what they want the result of that penalty to be, depending on where they are in the match or what they need at that precise moment. Say there are only two minutes left in a game and the score is tied, then a penalty is awarded just outside the try line. Does the team want the immediate three points, which is the safest guaranteed outcome? Or do they decide to kick for a lineout, maybe to reset their attack and try to force a try because they think the defending side might be gassed? It’s pure management of risk versus reward, hard out.
Context beats a bare stat.
Reply Quote
SW SweetAs_Mad Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 784 posts 1 Nov 2026, 1:28 pm
honestly, mate, it's just about the plan for the attack, see? you take that decision based on where you are in the game and what the opposition looks like, whether you need the three points right there or want to keep the pressure on. in short: the attacking team has the discretion to choose between scoring three points at the posts, taking an attacking lineout, or resetting play with a quick tap or scrum. seen this all before, the tactical part is usually bigger than the physical execution, always has been. 😄
Reply Quote
JoshBeliever wrote:
Ohh so the attacking team always gets to pick? That makes sense now, thanks ClassicFan 😄 But what if you tap and go and mess it up, do you lose the penalty altogether?
FR FrontRow_TillIDie Newcomer★☆☆☆☆ · 150 posts 11 Nov 2026, 2:15 am
@JoshBeliever yeah you pick, but pick wrong and you own it. Tap and go turns into a normal tackle situation, so if you get held up or knock it on you've chucked away a free three points for nothing. No second bite of the cherry either, ref's moved on 😏 Sort of like watching someone put a $20 multi on the TAB with legs they never should've included. The option was there, the decision was rubbish. Honest question back at you though, did you think the ref just handed out points or something? 😂
Any stat can be bent.
Reply Quote

Reply to thread

Log in to reply

No account? Sign up — it's quick.