Southland's back-to-back losses
Hi all, new here so go easy π
Honest question from someone still learning this stuff: does two straight losses really drop a guy off the Bledisloe radar? Southland getting beaten by Canterbury and Taranaki looks rough on paper, but I figured selectors watch individuals more than the scoreboard? Northland looking sharp against Wellington then losing to Counties Manukau a week later just confuses me more π€
Keen to hear what you older heads reckon before the 2 October game. Thanks in advance π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Welcome aboard, Wellington_15, and nah you've got it right π Individual form matters way more to the selectors than the scoreline tbh. We've leaked 55 points in two games and still had boys out there doing their jobs well. No way I'm dropping a Southland hopeful off my radar over a team effort gone wrong πͺ Scary part is Northland just smacked Wellington for 52, so 2 October at home is gonna be a proper test π₯
You don't abandon your own.
Mad, you'd say that wouldn't you π leaking 55 points in a fortnight and calling it job well done. Wellington_15's got it half right though β selectors do watch blokes individually, but when the whole backline's been smoked two weeks running, everyone's touch looks shabby on tape. Funny thing is Northland aren't exactly world beaters either, Counties sorted them out at home. Reckon the 2nd of October sorts the real form out, anyone putting Southland lads on a Bledisloe multi before then is just lighting NZ$ on fire π€‘πΈ
Show me your ROI first π
Napier's got a point about the tape, but I'd push back slightly on how much weight it carries. Two matches is a tiny sample, and context matters. Away trips to Canterbury and Taranaki are no picnic, whereas Northland's 52-pointer came against Wellington then they got reeled in by Counties Manukau a week later. If a Southland loosie or halfback is still hitting his targets and making his reads while the scoreline blows out, selectors will see that. I could be wrong, but I'd bet more punters get burned by judging off raw margins than by watching individual shifts properly. π
Context beats a bare stat.
Funny how a 52-28 win makes Northland "form line of the season" then they lose at home a week later π sure thing, mate, and in reality? One decent half from a Southland loosie beats any scoreboard noise π€‘
Here to argue, not to nod along.
Can I ask a probably dumb thing π
if both teams lost last weekend anyway, doesn't that sorta even everything out going into Invercargill? Feels odd picking who looked better when nobody won lol. Sorry if thats missing the point, just trying to learn how form works after back-to-back defs βΊοΈ
Dumb questions are my specialty.
SteveAuckland, nothing evens out for a punter. The TAB doesn't care that both teams lost, it cares how they lost π Southland getting smoked by 13 and 36 reads way different on the line than Northland going down by 3 at home. I put NZ$20 on Southland last week and it didn't land, so trust me, form lines cost real money π₯ Selection talk can hide behind small samples all it likes, the market's already voted.
Steve, form after two losses isn't "evened out" - margin and opposition quality both count. I'll rate Southland's hopefuls on individual tape, not scoreboard noise.
Hype isn't an argument.
Hmm, but if we're judging on "individual tape" like Queenstown51 says, doesn't the same logic save Southland's guys? A loosie can have a big defensive game in a 21:34 loss and it barely shows on the scoreboard π
Maybe I'm wrong, but Northland losing by 3 to Counties feels way less damning than Southland's two, so surely the margin does say something? π€
New here, soaking it up.
Scoreboard flatters Southland IMO, Northland put 52 on Wellington away, that's form you can build a Bledisloe case on πͺπ₯ Sorry fellas, Taniwha all day in Invercargill π
You don't abandon your own.
Quick question cos I'm still learning π
, StandsGuy, if Northland's 52 on Wellington is such a case builder, does the 19:22 loss to Counties Manukau at home undo some of it? Feels like everyone's picking the result that suits their bloke. Or am I reading that wrong π€
New here, soaking it up.
RobbedAgain asked the right question. Everyone cherry-picks, that's punting 101 π
My two bob: I've got a bit of Northland on the line for the 2nd and I still reckon the 52:28 tells you more than the Counties wobble, because Wellington away is a proper road win while Southland's two losses had no fight in either half. If my multi lands it'll be on Taniwha momentum, not tape-watching heroics πΈ
Value over a big price πΈ
Word going round the rusty traps down south is there's more bubbling under those two losses than anyone's letting on π€« Won't say who, but a source of mine reckons a couple of Southland boys will show the 2nd of October why the scoreboard never told the whole story. Those who know, know π Screenshot this.
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@Wing_Fan those kinds of whispers from the traps always make me nervous when I'm setting up a multi. If there's serious instability at Southland, you can't rely on the usual value. Last time a team I backed went through that kind of mess, it was all "on and forgotten" by the time kickoff hit. Seems like the volatility usually cancels out any ROI we try and carve out.
Bankroll discipline wins.
RobbedAgain's onto something, cherry-picking one result is how you torch a bankroll. Can't buy a price on either lot with any confidence while those whispers about Southland's camp are floating round. Left this one out of the multi entirely, value's nowhere near it.
Value over a big price πΈ
The guts they showed against Northland was solid man. Hope they sort out the rubbish tho... π€¬π₯
@Maul_Mate spot on about the guts. Guts only carries you so far if the errors keep stacking up though. Seen worse sides than that Southland lot, seen them come right too. Back in the day at Eden Park we watched teams lose two on the trot then turn the whole season, so I'd not write them off yet. The young lot never saw a proper rebuild like that. reckon what matters most is whether the whispers from down south are noise or the real thing. If it's just tired legs and a bad fortnight, they'll show up hard on the 2nd. If there's something festering in that camp, no amount of guts fixes it. Do you actually know what the "rubbish" is, or are you guessing like the rest of us? π
Seen it all, trust me.
The guts they showed against Northland was solid man. Hope they sort out the rubbish tho... π€¬π₯
@Maul_Mate guts was real, they never stopped hitting πͺ but them drops and penalties killing us. You just know they'll fix it, ah well, nowt to do π₯
In the stands since I was a kid.
Guts I'll give them, but those drops and penalties are killing my TAB multi more than my feelings π
watched the juniors I coach drop ball cold all training one week, coach made them catch wet sponges all session, they never dropped it again. Someone down there needs to do the same tbh π
You don't abandon your own.
Wet sponges at training, now there's a method π word going round the traps though is Southland's handling under fatigue has been a talking point for a wee while, not just this fortnight. Those who know, know. Won't say more here π€«
Those who know, know.