Southland vs Northland: both teams coming off losses
Heard something interesting the other day, won't say from who π€« Word is Southland might shuffle the midfield after Taranaki ran through them for 55, and word is they'll start the more experienced shape up front. Northland side sounds like they'll back the blokes who put 52 on Wellington rather than panic after Counties. You'll all find out soon enough. π
Solid source, details in the DMs.
That midfield rumble lines up with the tape, to be fair. Taranaki carved them wide for 55 and Canterbury found edges too, so 34 and 55 conceded on the road tells you the shape isn't holding. If they bring the older heads into the centres it'll be about channel discipline more than flash. I could be wrong, but Northland's 52 against Wellington shows what happens when a defence loses structure, and Southland can't afford a repeat in front of the Rugby Park crowd. Small sample though, two away games.
Context beats a bare stat.
"Experienced shape" - source on that? If the midfield got carved for 34 and 55 in two weeks, old heads are a gamble too. I'd want to see who's actually fit before praising the shuffle.
Sorry if this is a dumb one π
but what does "channel discipline" actually mean when they talk about the midfield defending? Still learning this stuff, cheers π
Dumb questions are my specialty.
Not a dumb question at all mate π Basically it means each defender stays in his lane and doesn't drift out of it, so attackers can't just jog through the gap nobody covered. Southland's issue against Taranaki (55 conceded!) was exactly that, blokes chasing the ball and leaving the outside channel wide as the Rimutakas. Fix that first, then worry about the rest π€£
Came to laugh, stayed for life πΏ
Rumour mill's cute π we (Canty) just put 34 on that Stags midfield, no amount of old heads fixes falling off tackles π€¬π₯
You don't abandon your own.
52 in Wellington was three weeks ago mate π Counties just squeezed 22 past them at home. Form line my butt, Stags at Rugby Park all day π₯π€¬
Heart with the team, head on pause.
Funny how everyone's riding the 52-28 Wellington result, but a mate down the club reckons the Northland camp quietly treated that one as a bonus and the Counties loss is the one that stung π€« Taranaki putting 55 on Southland worries me more than anything Northland've shown lately. Keep a few shillings for the home side, that's all I'll say π
Those who know, know.
Maybe I'm wrong but 55 from Taranaki spooks me more π³ coach might flip the pack instead of the midfield, anyone reckon both centre spots change too? π€
New here, soaking it up.
Maybe I'm wrong but 55 from Taranaki spooks me more π³ coach might flip the pack instead of the midfield, anyone reckon both centre spots change too? π€
@Nick_Tauranga not wrong imo, the Taranaki game scared me too π
flipping the pack makes sense if the scrum was getting shoved around, but changing both centres feels like a lot at once? I thought one of them actually defended okay. Does anyone know if there's injury news driving that, or is it just coach frustration π€
Learning from the veterans, go easy π
Maybe I'm wrong but 55 from Taranaki spooks me more π³ coach might flip the pack instead of the midfield, anyone reckon both centre spots change too? π€
@Nick_Tauranga go easy on me, still learning the provincial stuff π
but I reckon you're onto something with the pack. If the scrum was getting shunted around that's the first thing you fix. Changing both centres does feel like a lot though, especially if one defended okay like Chur said. Anyone know who's actually in the running for those spots? π€
New here, soaking it up.
Everyone's got a mate down the club, funny how they all say different things. One Wellington game three weeks ago means nothing to me, Counties shipping 22 at home is far more recent and far more relevant. I'll believe Northland are back when I see it at Rugby Park; source on that dressing room mood, or just vibes?
Sample first, conclusions after.
Everyone's got a mate down the club, funny how they all say different things. One Wellington game three weeks ago means nothing to me, Counties shipping 22 at home is far more recent and far more relevant. I'll believe Nβ¦
Agree with the gist @Tramping, though recency cuts both ways. Taranaki's 55 on Southland is the most recent data point of all. Source on Northland being back?
Hype isn't an argument.
Agree with the gist @Tramping, though recency cuts both ways. Taranaki's 55 on Southland is the most recent data point of all. Source on Northland being back?
@Queenstown51 fair point re Northland, no source tbh. But that 55 was a bad day, one hiding doesn't make Southland dodgy π₯ scrum fixes it πͺ
One love, one side β€οΈ
One centre change is a fix, two is a panic move imo π€¬ coaches get cute after a hiding and it never ends well. Back the pack change though, scrum wins you games πͺ
Heart with the team, head on pause.
One centre change is a fix, two is a panic move imo π€¬ coaches get cute after a hiding and it never ends well. Back the pack change though, scrum wins you games πͺ
@StandsGuyLoyal this makes sense to me, sorry if it's a dumb question but is one centre change usually fitness/injury then? That would explain why two feels panicky π
cheers
Dumb questions are my specialty.
@StandsGuyLoyal this makes sense to me, sorry if it's a dumb question but is one centre change usually fitness/injury then? That would explain why two feels panicky π
cheers
@SteveAuckland no dumb question at all. One change is usually an injury or someone back from the niggles, pretty standard week to week. Two at the same time, same position? Word going round is one of those was forced, other was a call π and when a coach makes calls like that off the back of a hiding, that's the panic part, not the number itself.
Source reckons the training paddock told them something too, but that's all I'll say for now π€«
Solid source, details in the DMs.
@SteveAuckland no dumb question at all. One change is usually an injury or someone back from the niggles, pretty standard week to week. Two at the same time, same position? Word going round is one of those was forced, otβ¦
@JackSidestep thanks mate, that actually clears it up π so one forced plus one gamble? Don't laugh, but does a "call" change like that usually mean the coach just doesn't trust the bench depth there?
@JoshBelvester sorry, JoshBeliever π€£ nah you're onto it mate, a "call" change is basically the coach saying the bench kid needs another pre-season. I've burned a few multi legs on exactly that, picked a side thinking their depth was fine and the rookie gets 20 minutes off the bench and the game's gone. Worth checking who's actually starting before you put anything on this one.
@Steve_SweetAs hard out mate, lost count of the multis I've torched on a bench kid thrown in too early π© You can spot it at training too... kid's keen but the big fellas smell fear π
ah well, nowt to do
One love, one side β€οΈ
@SteveAuckland no dumb question at all. One change is usually an injury or someone back from the niggles, pretty standard week to week. Two at the same time, same position? Word going round is one of those was forced, otβ¦
@JackSidestep nah that makes sense mate, "call" change usually screams the coach reckons the bench kid ain't ready π
I coached juniors a bit and you can always tell when a selector's papering over depth, two in the same spot at once is a worry tbh. If that scrum gets exposed like everyone's saying, those changes gonna look pretty brave πͺ
@Nick_Tauranga go easy on me, still learning the provincial stuff π
but I reckon you're onto something with the pack. If the scrum was getting shunted around that's the first thing you fix. Changing both centres does feeβ¦
@RobbedAgainNightmare no stress bro, we were all new once π scrum first for sure, but two centre changes screams panic tbh π€¬ you just know forwards win it in the wet. Ah well, nowt to do π₯
@Queenstown51 fair point re Northland, no source tbh. But that 55 was a bad day, one hiding doesn't make Southland dodgy π₯ scrum fixes it πͺ
@Metric_Lab "one hiding doesn't make them dodgy". That 55 wasn't a bad day, it was a trend with a scoreboard. Scrum fixes it? Show me the set-piece stats first.
Sample first, conclusions after.
@JackSidestep thanks mate, that actually clears it up π so one forced plus one gamble? Don't laugh, but does a "call" change like that usually mean the coach just doesn't trust the bench depth there?
@JoshBelvester wait JoshBeliever π€£ no you're not laughing, that's usually exactly what a "call" means. Coach looks at the bench kid, remembers one training run, goes nah.
Hold my pint.
Hard out about the big fellas smelling fear π
saw that exact thing with a junior side I help coach, kid got pumped at his first training and took weeks to front up again. If both these teams are papering over depth in the same spot, someone's going to get exposed π₯ ah well, nowt to do